Death in Paradise's Gary Carr: The Real Reason Behind Fidel Best's Exit & Why Fans Still Adore Him

The hit BBC One series Death in Paradise has seen many beloved characters come and go over the years. While fans are now embracing Don Gilet as Detective Mervin Wilson in the latest season, nostalgia has set in as they remember one of the original cast members—Fidel Best, played by Gary Carr.

Fidel Best: A Fan-Favorite from the Very Beginning

Fidel Best was introduced in the very first episode of Death in Paradise as the youngest member of the Honoré Police team. With a strong work ethic and ambition, he quickly became a cherished part of the squad. His character arc saw him grow not just as an officer but also as a family man.

His personal life took a joyous turn when his wife, Juliette, gave birth to their daughter, Rosie. Becoming a father pushed Fidel to work even harder, aspiring to climb the police ranks. He deeply respected his senior officers and was determined to follow in their footsteps.

Why Did Fidel Best Leave Death in Paradise?

As Fidel continued to develop professionally, his ambition led him to pursue a career beyond Saint Marie. He was encouraged to take the Sergeant exams, which he passed with distinction. Though this was an exciting moment for him, it also set the stage for his departure.

In Season 4, Fidel announced that he had accepted a promotion and would be transferring to the police force in St. Lucia. While his exit was written into the storyline, actor Gary Carr never publicly disclosed the exact reason for his departure.

However, co-star Kris Marshall, who played DI Humphrey Goodman, hinted in an interview with Digital Spy that Gary simply wanted to move on to new opportunities. He shared, "It wasn't a shock. I understand where he is coming from. I was just the same when I was younger. He wants to move on."

Fans Still Miss Fidel Best

Even years after his exit, Death in Paradise fans continue to express their admiration for Fidel Best. On Reddit, discussions ranking the best characters from the series frequently place Fidel in the top four.

One fan, Snowlock27, commented: "He was one of my favorites."

Another user, Steups13, expressed a desire for his return, saying: "I would like Fidel to come back as Detective Inspector."

Redditor Aaaggghhh_ echoed this sentiment, writing: "I still miss Fidel, he was funny and serious at the same time. It would have been good to see him back as the new Commissioner."

Similarly, Wheatson shared: "I adore him and I miss him so much."

Could Gary Carr Return to Death in Paradise?

While there has been no official word on a possible return, fans remain hopeful. Given the show's history of bringing back former characters—such as Camille Bordey (Sara Martins) and Florence Cassell (Joséphine Jobert)—there's always a chance that Fidel could make an unexpected comeback.

For now, Death in Paradise continues to entertain audiences every Friday at 9 pm on BBC One. Whether or not Fidel Best ever returns, his legacy as one of the most adored characters in the show's history remains firmly intact.

FAQs

1. Why did Gary Carr leave Death in Paradise?
Gary Carr never officially stated his reason for leaving, but his co-star Kris Marshall suggested that he simply wanted to move on to new projects.

2. Where did Fidel Best go in Death in Paradise?
Fidel Best left Saint Marie in Season 4 after passing his Sergeant exams and accepting a promotion to the police force in St. Lucia.

3. Could Fidel Best return to Death in Paradise?
While there is no confirmation, fans remain hopeful. The show has brought back former characters in the past, so a return isn’t entirely out of the question.

4. What has Gary Carr been doing since leaving Death in Paradise?
Since leaving the show, Gary Carr has appeared in various TV series, including The Deuce and 21 Bridges. He continues to work in film and television.

5. Who is the new detective in Death in Paradise?
Don Gilet has taken over as Detective Mervin Wilson in the latest season of Death in Paradise.